Message boards :
SETI@home Science :
We are alone in the universe
Message board moderation
Previous · 1 · 2 · 3 · 4 · 5 . . . 6 · Next
Author | Message |
---|---|
CJ Edwards Send message Joined: 25 Jun 99 Posts: 18 Credit: 21,857,042 RAC: 0 |
Nahhh. The Vulcans are just waiting to say Hi! When we create Warp Technology some time in the next handful of years, we will see. ;) We just need to get a couple of Elon Musk kind of people really interested in superluminal travel. |
Michael Watson Send message Joined: 7 Feb 08 Posts: 1384 Credit: 2,098,506 RAC: 5 |
That's illogical. The Vulcans are a fictional species. ; ) In general terms, it's not a bad scenario, though. Our extraterrestrial neighbors might want to have a word or two with us about getting along with the rest of the galaxy, before we go tearing off to the stars. Based on human behavior, they might want it to be a long talk, and sort of ease into our first meeting, very gradually. I used to think that something like a warp drive was a long time off. I'm not so sure anymore. Dr. Harold White at NASA has some promising ideas about this, and some encouraging, if somewhat ambiguous, experimental results. |
Neil Erickson Send message Joined: 15 May 99 Posts: 6 Credit: 13,475,029 RAC: 25 |
Hmmm... As much as I admire professor Brian Cox I find this statement very hard to accept. With the recent conclusion extrapolated from the rate of current exoplanet discoveries that nearly every star probably hosts a solar system of some type with planets (and our current methods of discovering exoplanets favor extreme examples of large gas giants in close fast orbits) and considering that there are hundreds of billions of stars in our own galaxy and considering that our most advanced telescopes straining all the way out to the time barrier of 13.8 billion light years away indicate that there are at least hundreds of billions of galaxies in the known universe, when you multiply that out and consider the unimaginable number of planets in the universe to conclude that our own tiny spec of dust is the only planet in the entire universe to have developed life and even the only one to host intelligent life is to me supreme self-important arrogance as a species equal to the dark ages belief that the Earth was the centre of the universe and that the entire universe was created solely for our benefit. Even for those with a religious viewpoint, given the vast distances and our current understanding of physics it is extremely unlikely that we would ever be able to visit more than a handful of other solar systems, so if a god exists would it not be an incredible waste to have created so many solar systems and not populate any others with life? As to the Fermi paradox question of why we haven't detected anything yet, as others have said: - I read several years ago that for another civilization at the same level as us to detect our electromagnetic transmissions they would only detect us if one of our most powerful military radars was aimed exactly in their direction and run at full power (and only if they happened to be listening in our direction and at that frequency at the time the signal passed them). - So much is said of our transmissions that have been leaking out into space for the last 70 years or so, but keep in mind that these transmissions dissipate rapidly in strength with distance, the incredible amount of background radiation noise out there being belched out by all the stars and the fantastical distances to even the nearest neighboring stars. It is highly unlikely that this accidental omnidirectional (not focused or beamed) radio leakage would even be detectable at the distance of our nearest interstellar neighbor. - In the 2 million year or so history of our species, it's only in the last handful of decades that we've had radio transmission technology, and now with more efficient digital technology, fiber optics, etc. our radio transmissions are becoming less and less powerful and would therefore propagate even less. - We've only been using radio technology for a few decades, who is to say that we don't progress to some other communications technology and if so, how short is the window of radio emissions for an advancing civilization? - Our latest estimates place the universe at approximately 13.8 billion years old. Of that 13.8 billion years our species has only been around for about 2 million years and only during the last few decades have we become technologically communicative - so chances are that any other civilizations out there are either far behind us or far more likely incredibly far ahead of us. That's not to say that we shouldn't keep trying however as the potential confirmation that we are not alone would just be too monumental and civilization changing a discovery to pass by and I have a lot of hope for the recent idea of trying to catch possible leakage of interplanetary communication in a distant solar system by targeting systems as multiple planets line up with us. Just the stray thoughts of a fellow space science/SETI/SciFi geek. LOL! ;-) |
tullio Send message Joined: 9 Apr 04 Posts: 8797 Credit: 2,930,782 RAC: 1 |
Man stands alone before a Universe he has not created and is indifferent to him. To him the choice between the Kingdom and darkness (Jacques Monod, "Chance and necessity", cited only by memory). Tullio |
Julie Send message Joined: 28 Oct 09 Posts: 34053 Credit: 18,883,157 RAC: 18 |
|
tullio Send message Joined: 9 Apr 04 Posts: 8797 Credit: 2,930,782 RAC: 1 |
Nature is wasteful. Think of the loss of spermatozoa before one and only one penetrates an egg. Tullio |
William Rothamel Send message Joined: 25 Oct 06 Posts: 3756 Credit: 1,999,735 RAC: 4 |
Finding life--even plant life--say, on Mars would go a long way to wiping out the God thing and the notion that we are unique in the Universe. Since we share a not insignificant percent of our genes with common weeds---one may extrapolate to the idea that; given a nearly identical Earth-like planet and a few billion years; that intelligent life is likely elsewhere in the cosmos. The trick then becomes finding an "Earth" with all of the necessary parameters in the right range. I don't think that such planets are common; but I can imagine that there might be a handful in each galaxy. So I say lets find evidence of life on Mars etc and then lets find this other "Earth". I don't expect to see this happen in my remaining lifetime but it is intriguing to hope and watch. |
tullio Send message Joined: 9 Apr 04 Posts: 8797 Credit: 2,930,782 RAC: 1 |
On "Nature" there is an article which I cannot link, but it says that exoplanets hunters are uniting their front to ask NASA a planet hunting space telescope (WFIRST), which was already proposed but never financed. But it will take years to build and launch it, provided it is funded. Tullio |
Bob DeWoody Send message Joined: 9 May 10 Posts: 3387 Credit: 4,182,900 RAC: 10 |
It depends on the perceived relative need to discover such a planet in the near future. I agree that in the end mankind, or whatever we evolve to be, will need to find another place to live but that is so far off as not to be a good argument now. Even though I firmly believe there are other intelligent beings out there, for now and for most intents and purposes we are quite alone, Bob DeWoody My motto: Never do today what you can put off until tomorrow as it may not be required. This no longer applies in light of current events. |
Julie Send message Joined: 28 Oct 09 Posts: 34053 Credit: 18,883,157 RAC: 18 |
It depends on the perceived relative need to discover such a planet in the near future. I agree that in the end mankind, or whatever we evolve to be, will need to find another place to live but that is so far off as not to be a good argument now. Even though I firmly believe there are other intelligent beings out there, for now and for most intents and purposes we are quite alone, Imagine what it would do to societies if they knew and had proof! Mass hysteria! You're probably right Bob, it's for the best that most people on this planet think we're alone... For crying out loud, they even put people in psychiatry for having such thoughts grmpf, makes me think of Nicolaus Copernicus who was grounded by Catholic church because of his revolutionary ideas... rOZZ Music Pictures |
tullio Send message Joined: 9 Apr 04 Posts: 8797 Credit: 2,930,782 RAC: 1 |
Copernicus was very cautious and was never condemned. It was Galileo who was condemned to house confinement in his villa "Il gioiello" on the Arcetri hill for divulging Copernican ideas. But the Jesuit astronomers, led by Father Orazio Grassi, SJ, already knew the Copernican ideas but kept them to themselves. Tullio |
Julie Send message Joined: 28 Oct 09 Posts: 34053 Credit: 18,883,157 RAC: 18 |
|
William Rothamel Send message Joined: 25 Oct 06 Posts: 3756 Credit: 1,999,735 RAC: 4 |
We may well be able to converse albeit with huge pauses--but we had better listen carefully for if we say "WHAT" we may have just lost 60,000 years. |
Julie Send message Joined: 28 Oct 09 Posts: 34053 Credit: 18,883,157 RAC: 18 |
Imagine what it would do to societies if they knew and had proof! Mass hysteria! You're probably right Bob, it's for the best that most people on this planet think we're alone... For crying out loud, they even put people in psychiatry for having such thoughts grmpf, makes me think of Nicolaus Copernicus who was grounded by Catholic church because of his revolutionary ideas... Still, I'm a believer Chris... rOZZ Music Pictures |
Julie Send message Joined: 28 Oct 09 Posts: 34053 Credit: 18,883,157 RAC: 18 |
So am I Julie, in that "they" basically exist. I am also a believer that "they" were here before roughly 11-15,000 BC, but I don't believe that they are here now. I also believe that if I'm right "they" would have left a calling card somewhere, in such a manner that we wouldn't find it and understand it until we were ready for it. That was the whole idea of the original black monolith on the moon in the Odyssey sci fi series. Duncan Lunan predicted a probe at one of the Lagrange points. A big +1 to the last paragraph! We are not ready yet to meet ET. If those UFO sightings are reality then it's very striking 'they' also leave after a short time and don't stay. I think 'they' don't find us worthy to have any contact with (yet). A highly civilized being in its 'UFO' can scan the area and its population quite fast I presume. (that's just guessing I know but could be a theory) rOZZ Music Pictures |
Julie Send message Joined: 28 Oct 09 Posts: 34053 Credit: 18,883,157 RAC: 18 |
A highly civilized being in its 'UFO' can scan the area and its population quite fast I presume. (that's just guessing I know but could be a theory) It sure does. rOZZ Music Pictures |
KLiK Send message Joined: 31 Mar 14 Posts: 1304 Credit: 22,994,597 RAC: 60 |
"It's life Jim, but not as we know it." Exactly! All I know so far: Life always finds a way! ;) non-profit org. Play4Life in Zagreb, Croatia, EU |
Larry Monske Send message Joined: 17 Sep 05 Posts: 281 Credit: 554,328 RAC: 0 |
The Drake equation is wrong. Life such as us require a refined atmosphere with air pressure and gas mixes to support life within narrow limits. The bacterium of the planet must be tolerable to the species.The planet must have a certain climate or life isnt possible. The point is earth sized planet with some of these requirements is so rare we cant imagine in our galaxy there could be another but to be a copy of earth makes it impossible. Bigger , smaller, close in or a moon of a gas giant life like us will be rare. We have to search to star clusters of old stable stars with time for life to grow. |
Larry Monske Send message Joined: 17 Sep 05 Posts: 281 Credit: 554,328 RAC: 0 |
lets see Russians found plankton on the surface of the ISS that have been exposed to vacuum and UV solar radiation and no water. The common plankton is found on the surface of the sea. And when assembly took place for parts of the ISS exposed to sea fog. 20 years in a vacuum I think it would be safe to say that zoo plankton came from space and survives the rigors is truly amazing and its like oh well earth plankton can survive in space. The temperature is 390 degrees swing from day to light every 90 minutes. The nutty thing is that something has been drawing down energy production and was thought that thrusters firing are leaving residue on solar arrays. The swipes are from the ISS surface. |
Julie Send message Joined: 28 Oct 09 Posts: 34053 Credit: 18,883,157 RAC: 18 |
We are alone in the universe: Professor Brian Cox says alien life is all but impossible and humanity is 'unique' Working at CERN ey? Saying we are alone in the Universe and that we are unique ey, hmmmm, VERY interesting............. Wondering what else those scientists might think over there.......... rOZZ Music Pictures |
©2024 University of California
SETI@home and Astropulse are funded by grants from the National Science Foundation, NASA, and donations from SETI@home volunteers. AstroPulse is funded in part by the NSF through grant AST-0307956.