Posts by Dr.Okun_@_SETI.USA

1) Message boards : Technical News : Fast One (May 16 2007) (Message 572899)
Posted 21 May 2007 by Profile Dr.Okun_@_SETI.USA
Post:
When the paid staff is absent durring a crisis this is NOT a good sign.

It's not?
Oh, so people don't get weekends or holidays off any more?
Please, it's a volunteer project- if it's that important to you i suggest you take a break & come to terms with reality & re-evaluate your priorities.
The expression "Get a life" comes to mind.


You only quoted part of my post and take it out of context. Nice try at twisting reality.

As I posted... in absence of someone they must have a sufficient plan B. You say it is a volunteer project... for who? There are wages being paid to some in the project. I have no issue with them getting their vacations (as I had stated in my post but you failed to comprehend), but while they are away, a project of this magnitude cannot be left in the hands of less capable people. There has to be someone left in charge that has equal abilities to the project leader as well as project knowledge.

Please, we are volenteers for this project- if it's NOT important to you I suggest you leave the project with your reality and re-evaluate YOUR priorities. The expression "juvenile" comes to mind.
2) Message boards : Technical News : Fast One (May 16 2007) (Message 572834)
Posted 21 May 2007 by Profile Dr.Okun_@_SETI.USA
Post:


The frustration some feel is only a human feeling, falsified and intensified (for some) by a certain level of expectation that the project never promised. Indeed, holding one man "to the cross" because he has a life or is in need of a previously planned vacation is a little (lot?) ridiculous and unfair. The expectation that Matt should somehow give up his music (full time job) or not go on vacation just because the project is having problems (and somehow can't survive without him?) is quite the expectation. An expectation that I would not want to be on the receiving end of, and I feel for the SAH team.


I've seen somewhere on these boards that the "team" consists of 5 people. Two mainly admins and three to do the real work. Matt
I beleive is one of the "PAID"employees there week days. If his music is also a "full time job" He's not doing justice to either job. One
is not a priority anymore. It's also apparent from this weeks events that things did not survive very well without him.

When the paid staff is absent durring a crisis this is NOT a good sign. Maybe it's time for a staff shake up or at least a wake up call.

Just my observations & 2 cents


The project's importance is directly measured by the importance of those who make it function. Thus if one may be gone for an extended period and no legitimate back-up exists, this indicates a lack of importance of this project.

In other words UC Berkeley needs to back this program properly or give it up to a worthy recipient.

There is no problem with giving people their well deserved time off. There is a problem with not having a sufficient plan B for their absence.
3) Message boards : Technical News : Fast One (May 16 2007) (Message 569901)
Posted 18 May 2007 by Profile Dr.Okun_@_SETI.USA
Post:
You call it complaining, I call it open discussion. Agree to disagree as I will discuss what I want when I want.

Your political observation is far too vague to be accurate. In fact, if they can't keep it going, then who will take it? Give that thought for the future when this project runs out of funding. Some collaboration between Universities does seem in order assuming people can get off their high horses and loose the ego's.
4) Message boards : Technical News : Fast One (May 16 2007) (Message 569680)
Posted 17 May 2007 by Profile Dr.Okun_@_SETI.USA
Post:
Sounds like they need a professional grant writer. Most government grants are applied for via professional grant writers who truly understand the process and have a good track record of receiving grants for their clients.

Also sounds like UC should find a University more willing to take the handcuffs off of the project so it has the opportunity to thrive. Contact the University of Wisconsin.

Let me guess, UC has a rule on contacting other Universities too... not to mention the staff has no desire to cut their own jobs.
5) Message boards : Technical News : Fast One (May 16 2007) (Message 569498)
Posted 17 May 2007 by Profile Dr.Okun_@_SETI.USA
Post:
Project/Task
Subtotal
Total

SETI@home I


$65,700

Offline Data Analysis & RFI Rejection
$22,000



Candidate Identification
37,500



Followup Observations of Best Candidates
6,200



SETI@home II


149,200

New Client Application Software Development
98,800



Candidate Identification & Data Analysis Software
50,400



Astropulse ¹


92,700

Client application/data analysis software development
45,000



Equipment: Database and server hardware
19,400



Candidate identification and followup observations
28,300



Operations


230,400

Internet connection and bandwidth charges
59,700



Database administration and support
48,500



Systems administration and support
62,800



Server maintainence and preformance monitoring
20,900



Web site development
25,200



Upgrade to failure tolerant server configuration
13,300





Total
538,000


Astropulse
The current SETI@home application looks for signals that are narrow in frequency, but have long duration. That's one way that an extraterrestrial civilization can send a signal that stands up above the radio background noise. Another possibility is that they could put a lot of power into a short duration pulsed signal that has a wide bandwidth. As such a pulse travels through intestellar space, interactions with interstellar matter slow down low frequencies relative to high frequencies in a process called dispersion. This dispersion spreads the pulse out over time. If we know how much dispersion a pulse has experienced, we can correct for this effect. For an extraterrestrial signal we won't know how much interstellar matter the signal interacted with on its journey, therefore we have to try every possible dispersion measure. That takes a lot of computing time.

Astropulse is a SETI@home application that uses coherent dedispersion to search for pulsed signals. In addition to extraterrestrial signals we might see signs of evaporating black holes or discover new pulsars. You can read more about Astropulse here .

Both Astropulse AND current seti@home use the same servers, perhaps they both benefit if not having to go down due to equipment failure. I am sure the NSF assumed the computers were functional when they funded the project and that they would need upgrading at some point. Has anyone attempted to gain new funding from the NSF for server upgrades?
6) Message boards : Technical News : Fast One (May 16 2007) (Message 569470)
Posted 17 May 2007 by Profile Dr.Okun_@_SETI.USA
Post:
Perhaps they should consider tabling astropulse and use that portion of the budget to purchase more servers.
7) Message boards : Technical News : Can't talk.. Debugging.. (May 15 2007) (Message 568808)
Posted 16 May 2007 by Profile Dr.Okun_@_SETI.USA
Post:
Thinking the best move is to totally block internet regions while others are allowed to upload to the project. Do a round robin of blockages until the project is caught up with the demand.





 
©2026 University of California
 
SETI@home and Astropulse are funded by grants from the National Science Foundation, NASA, and donations from SETI@home volunteers. AstroPulse is funded in part by the NSF through grant AST-0307956.