Does intelligent design theory implement the scientific method?

留言板 : Politics : Does intelligent design theory implement the scientific method?
留言板合理

To post messages, you must log in.

前 · 1 · 2

作者消息
Profile Sarge
志愿者测试人员

发送消息
已加入:25 Aug 99
贴子:11664
积分:8,569,109
近期平均积分:79
United States
消息 1436732 - 发表于:1 Nov 2013, 23:26:21 UTC - 回复消息 1436656.  

Does intelligent design theory implement the scientific method?


It is poor netiquette to have 3 separate threads on the same topic all coming from the same poster.

1) "They then seek to find CSI. One easily testable form of CSI is irreducible complexity (IC)." In the sciences, the terms must not be ambiguous. You cannot form a researchable question upon ambiguous terms. The term "irreducible complexity" assumes the observation and the desired conclusion.

2) "If they find them [supposed evidence of IC], they can conclude design." No. Very unscientific. They should be calculating the probability it was due to design or the probability it was not due to design. (Now, how do they propose to do THAT?!?) Even if the probability it was not due to design turned out to be very low, it could still be not due to design! Perhaps a lurking variable has been ignored.

3) " Language and machines are good examples of things with much CSI. From our understanding of the world, high levels of CSI are always the product of intelligent design." Who's understanding? Wait. What?!? OK, please find me evidence of the first humans that spoke and evidence that they designed language and how.

From the table:
4) "Similar parts found in different organisms. Many genes and functional parts not distributed in a manner predicted by ancestry, and are often found in clearly unrelated organisms. The "root" of the tree of life is a prime example." Why did the creator(s) choose to repeat themselves? Functional things could be made in so many ways! So, it must be they said, "Hey, we've found something that works. Let's stick without. We could go around being original for each and every life-form we create ... errr, design, but heck, we're ust happy we could do it this once."

ID: 1436732 · 举报违规帖子
Profile Intelligent Design
Avatar

发送消息
已加入:9 Apr 12
贴子:3626
积分:37,520
近期平均积分:0
United States
消息 1436706 - 发表于:1 Nov 2013, 22:59:22 UTC

It sure does and the link proved that very fact. This question has been asked many, many times of me and I have said that ID does used the scientific method and here is your proof of that very fact.
Must not conflict resolve by suggesting that someone should go sit on an ice pick...
ID: 1436706 · 举报违规帖子
Profile Wiggo "Democratic Socialist"
Avatar

发送消息
已加入:24 Jan 00
贴子:18821
积分:261,360,520
近期平均积分:489
Australia
消息 1436666 - 发表于:1 Nov 2013, 20:58:23 UTC

And never will.

Cheers.
ID: 1436666 · 举报违规帖子
W-K 666 Project Donor
志愿者测试人员

发送消息
已加入:18 May 99
贴子:13920
积分:40,757,560
近期平均积分:67
United Kingdom
消息 1436664 - 发表于:1 Nov 2013, 20:54:50 UTC

No and never has done.
ID: 1436664 · 举报违规帖子
Profile Intelligent Design
Avatar

发送消息
已加入:9 Apr 12
贴子:3626
积分:37,520
近期平均积分:0
United States
消息 1436656 - 发表于:1 Nov 2013, 20:31:49 UTC

Does intelligent design theory implement the scientific method?
Must not conflict resolve by suggesting that someone should go sit on an ice pick...
ID: 1436656 · 举报违规帖子
前 · 1 · 2

留言板 : Politics : Does intelligent design theory implement the scientific method?


 
©2020 University of California
 
SETI@home and Astropulse are funded by grants from the National Science Foundation, NASA, and donations from SETI@home volunteers. AstroPulse is funded in part by the NSF through grant AST-0307956.