Lies about WMD?

留言板 : Politics : Lies about WMD?
留言板合理

To post messages, you must log in.

前 · 1 · 2

作者消息
Profile Gone with the wind Crowdfunding Project Donor*Special Project $75 donorSpecial Project $250 donor
志愿者测试人员

发送消息
已加入:19 Nov 00
贴子:41732
积分:42,645,437
近期平均积分:42
消息 1412914 - 发表于:8 Sep 2013, 14:42:35 UTC

Plenty available if one looks.....

Good links, thanks.
ID: 1412914 · 举报违规帖子
Profile Bill Walker
Avatar

发送消息
已加入:4 Sep 99
贴子:3868
积分:2,697,267
近期平均积分:0
Canada
消息 1412911 - 发表于:8 Sep 2013, 14:39:55 UTC

It never fails to amaze me how the American press is able to reduce everything to the level of petty party politics. We see them still apologizing for Bush's "honest mistakes", at the same time they are condemning Obama's attempts to legally go to war as "el Qaeda’s Air Force". I wonder what the press coverage would be like if they had a Republican president, or even a white Democrat president?

ID: 1412911 · 举报违规帖子
Sirius B Project Donor
志愿者测试人员
Avatar

发送消息
已加入:26 Dec 00
贴子:21912
积分:3,081,182
近期平均积分:7
Ireland
消息 1412902 - 发表于:8 Sep 2013, 14:30:51 UTC - 回复消息 1412852.  

a map that showed the Iraqis had rockets that could reach as far as Cyprus with WMD warheads, this was not true and they knew it, and when questioned, they sort of agreed, but did not put out a retraction.

Got any more info on that?



Plenty available if one looks.....

Whitehall & the Iraq War

"The government had committed several blunders here. The schoolboy-style plagiarism cast a veil of dishonesty over all the material issued in ‘dossier’ form."

The Iraq Inquiry

Iraq 10 years on
ID: 1412902 · 举报违规帖子
Profile Gone with the wind Crowdfunding Project Donor*Special Project $75 donorSpecial Project $250 donor
志愿者测试人员

发送消息
已加入:19 Nov 00
贴子:41732
积分:42,645,437
近期平均积分:42
消息 1412852 - 发表于:8 Sep 2013, 10:08:15 UTC

a map that showed the Iraqis had rockets that could reach as far as Cyprus with WMD warheads, this was not true and they knew it, and when questioned, they sort of agreed, but did not put out a retraction.

Got any more info on that?

ID: 1412852 · 举报违规帖子
W-K 666 Project Donor
志愿者测试人员

发送消息
已加入:18 May 99
贴子:13920
积分:40,757,560
近期平均积分:67
United Kingdom
消息 1412844 - 发表于:8 Sep 2013, 9:30:57 UTC - 回复消息 1412837.  

I think that the reports of Saddam having WMD came from a source, that at best could be described as, double check everything he says. But Dubya and a persuaded Blair were prepared to grasp anything that made a case for action.

Also in the pre-war government report by the British government there was a map that showed the Iraqis had rockets that could reach as far as Cyprus with WMD warheads, this was not true and they knew it, and when questioned, they sort of agreed, but did not put out a retraction. This was probably one of the "facts" that meant the great unwashed were prepared to back action, when you consider Cyprus is a popular holiday destination for the Brits and quite a few would have or had service personnel serving in the 3 Sovereign base areas.
ID: 1412844 · 举报违规帖子
Profile Gone with the wind Crowdfunding Project Donor*Special Project $75 donorSpecial Project $250 donor
志愿者测试人员

发送消息
已加入:19 Nov 00
贴子:41732
积分:42,645,437
近期平均积分:42
消息 1412837 - 发表于:8 Sep 2013, 8:57:59 UTC

I think there are two points to be made here.

1. After 9/11 Bush wanted revenge, and had an itchy trigger finger. Saddam was the first to pop his head up over the parapet so he got it first.

2. At the time the CIA and MI5 both agreed Iraq had WMD and would use them, and Bush was quite willing to go to war on what he was told by them.

Bush launched a second Gulf War, despite multiple dissenting opinions and questions of integrity about the underlying intelligence. Later U.S.-led inspections agreed that Iraq had earlier abandoned its WMD programs, but asserted Iraq had an intention to pursue those programs if UN sanctions were ever lifted.

Bush later said that the biggest regret of his presidency was "the intelligence failure" in Iraq, while the Senate Intelligence Committee found in 2008 that his administration "misrepresented the intelligence and the threat from Iraq". A key CIA informant in Iraq admitted that he lied about his allegations, "then watched in shock as it was used to justify the war".

I don't think there were specific lies, made up facts, or misrepresentations, just handy reports that were readily believable, suited the purpose, and weren't as double checked as they should have been.

ID: 1412837 · 举报违规帖子
Profile Robert Waite
Avatar

发送消息
已加入:23 Oct 07
贴子:2417
积分:18,192,122
近期平均积分:59
Canada
消息 1412662 - 发表于:7 Sep 2013, 18:19:52 UTC

In the interests of civility, let's not call what Bush told us "lies".
Instead of "lies", let's call them "made up facts".
I do not fight fascists because I think I can win.
I fight them because they are fascists.
Chris Hedges

A riot is the language of the unheard. -Martin Luther King, Jr.
ID: 1412662 · 举报违规帖子
Profile betreger Project Donor
Avatar

发送消息
已加入:29 Jun 99
贴子:10354
积分:29,581,041
近期平均积分:66
United States
消息 1412659 - 发表于:7 Sep 2013, 17:36:23 UTC - 回复消息 1412489.  

I agree, the shrub did not lie about WMDs what he is guilty of is going to war with hastily vetted evidence some of which was a lie.


Don't you mean, "some of which was wrong."

There's a difference.

No, I mean lies by Rafid Ahmed Alwan al-Janabi.
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/feb/15/defector-admits-wmd-lies-iraq-war
ID: 1412659 · 举报违规帖子
Profile Gone with the wind Crowdfunding Project Donor*Special Project $75 donorSpecial Project $250 donor
志愿者测试人员

发送消息
已加入:19 Nov 00
贴子:41732
积分:42,645,437
近期平均积分:42
消息 1412642 - 发表于:7 Sep 2013, 16:54:29 UTC

The Iraqi intelligence service did a masterful job. Everyone likes to forget that they were proclaiming they had WMD's. Back that up with a nice feint of having conferences out at some remote building with the "right" people forced to attend, and some heavy truck traffic and guess what, you have a WMD program.

It's called sabre rattling and it worked. The trouble is when you are the one listening, do you take a chance that is what it actually is or not?

ID: 1412642 · 举报违规帖子
Profile Gary Charpentier Crowdfunding Project Donor*Special Project $75 donorSpecial Project $250 donor
志愿者测试人员
Avatar

发送消息
已加入:25 Dec 00
贴子:27228
积分:53,134,872
近期平均积分:32
United States
消息 1412600 - 发表于:7 Sep 2013, 14:59:03 UTC

The Iraqi intelligence service did a masterful job. Everyone likes to forget that they were proclaiming they had WMD's. Back that up with a nice feint of having conferences out at some remote building with the "right" people forced to attend, and some heavy truck traffic and guess what, you have a WMD program.

ID: 1412600 · 举报违规帖子
tbret
志愿者测试人员
Avatar

发送消息
已加入:28 May 99
贴子:3380
积分:296,162,071
近期平均积分:40
United States
消息 1412489 - 发表于:7 Sep 2013, 4:52:27 UTC - 回复消息 1412421.  

I agree, the shrub did not lie about WMDs what he is guilty of is going to war with hastily vetted evidence some of which was a lie.


Don't you mean, "some of which was wrong."

There's a difference.
ID: 1412489 · 举报违规帖子
Profile betreger Project Donor
Avatar

发送消息
已加入:29 Jun 99
贴子:10354
积分:29,581,041
近期平均积分:66
United States
消息 1412421 - 发表于:7 Sep 2013, 0:14:36 UTC - 回复消息 1412414.  

I agree, the shrub did not lie about WMDs what he is guilty of is going to war with hastily vetted evidence some of which was a lie.
ID: 1412421 · 举报违规帖子
tbret
志愿者测试人员
Avatar

发送消息
已加入:28 May 99
贴子:3380
积分:296,162,071
近期平均积分:40
United States
消息 1412414 - 发表于:6 Sep 2013, 23:47:24 UTC

I tire of seeing people repeat that W lied to attack Iraq.

I get so tired of "opinion" and "popular bs" masquerading as knowledge.

If you want to stop sounding like just one more moron repeating what someone else told you to hear, there are ways to inform yourself.

I suggest you watch the whole thing (because it is interesting and not technical), but if you only have a minute or two watch a few minutes of this video, taken from that vast right-wing conspiratorial stronghold, a lecture hall at The University of California at Berkeley.

This is delivered by a guy who is hyper-concerned about man-made global warming. If you are going to accuse him of a bias, please tell me what his bias is.

The quick information you need is at 41:50.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5BHdsjo-NR4


This is not actually the best one of these compilations I have seen, it omits a lot, but it is quick and useful:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cwqh4wQPoQk

Another:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FCVZlLBchVE




It seems to me that I remember before the second gulf war seeing video of truck after truck after truck full of "something" unidentified streaming into Syria from Iraq. I may be making this up, but when the war started I think the forces were very quickly concerned about sealing the border with Syria.

"W" is hardly my favorite President. He did so much that I cannot excuse that I am ashamed of him. He was wrong about whether WMD were IN IRAQ at that moment in time. He didn't "lie" about it unless you want to say everyone was lying about it.


I'm not saying I know what is going-on in Syria now. I'm absolutely certain I don't. But I'm not going to let someone else tell me what I should think about the facts and draw my conclusions for me. Too many years of too much smoke being blown up my _____.

I **remember** a press conference with Madeline Albright and John Kerry trying to push President Clinton into a war with Iraq.

I don't want to hear about Bush's lies anymore. At least not among a group of enlightened people here. If you aren't enlightened, you didn't click the links.

ID: 1412414 · 举报违规帖子
前 · 1 · 2

留言板 : Politics : Lies about WMD?


 
©2020 University of California
 
SETI@home and Astropulse are funded by grants from the National Science Foundation, NASA, and donations from SETI@home volunteers. AstroPulse is funded in part by the NSF through grant AST-0307956.