I've been asked to repost this from our boards. The original thread and post can be found here

While I won't recommend it to my team, there is a third option which I took. That's staying away from seti for the foreseeable future. I can tollerate alot of things, but people being stupid isn't generally one of them.

repost:
----------------
I don't tend to blame the seti project guys because I understand that they're working on a shoestring budget, but the decision to upgrade boinc versions during the most severe outage of the BOINC era is sheer stupidity.

You don't introduce new potential points of failure until everything else is stable. How else are you going to be able to tell where problems come from?

You don't introduce a new version of any software before you assess the potential impact on your user base.

Sorry, but the seti team made a stupid decision in this case. Not because of low budgets, not because of being overworked, but because of very bad decision making and defective logic.

-------------------


Xaak
Team Starfire World BOINC
Join Us
IRC Chat: irc://irc.teamstarfire.net:6667/team_starfire

---

XaaK

Thanks, Xaak, for echoing our thoughts, from TSWB. Since we are a new team comprised of long time DC folk, most all of run optimized apps. This has affected most of our team.

Hopefully tomorrow, the Seti staff can sit down and see what can be done with fixing the BOINC Server code's 5.09 anonymous platform breakage.

Paul

---

Team Starfire World BOINC
IRC- irc//irc.teamstarfire.net:6667/team_starfire

I've been asked to repost this from our boards. The original thread and post can be found here

While I won't recommend it to my team, there is a third option which I took. That's staying away from seti for the foreseeable future. I can tollerate alot of things, but people being stupid isn't generally one of them.

repost:
----------------
I don't tend to blame the seti project guys because I understand that they're working on a shoestring budget, but the decision to upgrade boinc versions during the most severe outage of the BOINC era is sheer stupidity.

You don't introduce new potential points of failure until everything else is stable. How else are you going to be able to tell where problems come from?

You don't introduce a new version of any software before you assess the potential impact on your user base.

Sorry, but the seti team made a stupid decision in this case. Not because of low budgets, not because of being overworked, but because of very bad decision making and defective logic.

-------------------
Please excuse me I am a tolerent person but get a life. we are donating computer power, this is not a bussiness.They owe us nothing not even the ability to use optomized apps.
sorry to rant but when stupip people call someone else stupid I get a little Irate.

---

Please excuse me I am a tolerent person but get a life. we are donating computer power, this is not a bussiness.They owe us nothing not even the ability to use optomized apps.
sorry to rant but when stupip people call someone else stupid I get a little Irate.

No one called anyone stupid except for you James. Actually, you called him stupip so we can forgive you. ;-)

It was the action taken which wasn't very smart, but I tend to do stupid things like that too.

---

Join Team Starfire
BOINC Chat

/snip
Sorry, but the seti team made a stupid decision in this case. Not because of low budgets, not because of being overworked, but because of very bad decision making and defective logic.

-------------------
Please excuse me I am a tolerent person but get a life. we are donating computer power, this is not a bussiness.They owe us nothing not even the ability to use optomized apps.
sorry to rant but when stupip people call someone else stupid I get a little Irate.

Xaak
Team Starfire World BOINC
Join Us
IRC Chat: irc://irc.teamstarfire.net:6667/team_starfire

James, you're not helping your cause out much with a post like that. ;-)

While Xaak's tone may be a bit on the harsh side, his message is clear. Why on earth would the project introduce a new version of the server code in the middle of the The Biggest SETI Outage Ever (TBSOE) is beyond me.

I've known Xaak for many years now, and we both are quite passionate in our DC hobby, having spent several 10's of thousands of dollars between us on hardware and electricity in the past few years alone. For us to expect that common practices in the IT business be adhered to is fair to me.

---

Team Starfire World BOINC
IRC- irc//irc.teamstarfire.net:6667/team_starfire

Please excuse me I am a tolerent person but get a life. we are donating computer power, this is not a bussiness.They owe us nothing not even the ability to use optomized apps.
sorry to rant but when stupip people call someone else stupid I get a little Irate.

You might get a bigger I-rate if you'd learn to spell.

I hear a pot calling a kettle black.

---

-------------------
Please excuse me I am a tolerent person but get a life. we are donating computer power, this is not a bussiness.They owe us nothing not even the ability to use optomized apps.
sorry to rant but when stupip people call someone else stupid I get a little Irate.

You come off very insulting for a supposedly tolerent person. If you have to tell others you are... (But let's not go there :-) )


There's a big difference between calling someone stupid or insulting someone directly (as you did to me), and calling a decision stupid. The fact is it was a stupid decision, regardless of how brilliant the people were who made it.

And yes, I'm a volunteer and donor of both computer time and funds directly. As such I'm not getting paid to tollerate this situation, and I choose to volunteer and donate elsewhere until this team gets their act together.

And, for your info, I have a great life. I have opinions too and I'll voice them as I please. :-)
Xaak
Team Starfire World Boinc
Join Us
IRC Chat: irc://irc.teamstarfire.net:6667/team_starfire

---

XaaK